Wednesday, 10 October 2012

Court Dismisses N200m Compensation Suit Filed By Gbenga Daniel Against EFCC

 

In dismissing the suit, Justice Folasade Ojo held that the EFCC acted within the limits of its statutory powers, when it arrested and detained Daniel.

Ojo held that Section 6 of the EFCC Establishment Act 2004 confers on the commission the powers to investigate and prosecute economic and financial crimes.

She also held that the arrest and detention of Daniel on suspicion that he siphoned about N7 billion from the state treasury during his eight-year rule, was lawful and justifiable.

The judge further held that under the laws setting up the EFCC, anybody could be invited, arrested and detained for a certain period of time.

``The commission can accept and institute criminal charges against any agency whether state or federal or any individual, organisation or entity,'' Ojo said.

She said that from the evidence the EFCC brought to court, the commission showed that it granted Daniel administrative bail on Oct. 7, 2011, after taking a statement from him.

Ojo further held that the conditions in which bail was granted to Daniel were that ``he brings two sureties who must be serving directors and also had landed properties’’.

The second condition, she said was that Daniel should deposit his international passport with the EFCC.

``The evidence before me as provided by the EFCC shows that he was granted administrative bail with some conditions to be met.

``I find the conditions upon which bail was granted liberal enough.

``So, how can he explain to court, what he declared in his affidavit that he was not able to meet the bail conditions because the terms on which he was granted bail, were too harsh.

``I find this hard to believe. How can a former governor not be able to produce two serving directors in a ministry as sureties?

``Or is it the part that says deposit your international passport that is harsh for him to meet,'' she asked, and held that Daniel had failed to establish that he was unlawfully detained.

``I have carefully looked at this case. The plaintiff has failed to show that his stay in the EFCC custody for seven days amounts to a breach of his fundamental human rights.

``I, therefore, hold that this application for compensation for violation of human rights lacks merit and is hereby dismissed,'' she held.

Daniel had urged the court to hold that his arrest and detention by operatives of the EFCC from Oct. 6 to Oct. 12, 2011 at the Asokoro Headquarters of the commission, was unconstitutional and a violation of his freedom of movement.

Daniel told the court that he was unlawfully detained for seven days without being charged for any offence.

He prayed the court to order the EFCC to pay him N200 million as damages, for what he called ``psychological torture, harassment and threat''.

Daniel also prayed the court to hold that his detention for seven days was unconstitutional and a violation of his rights under the constitution.

He wants the EFCC to tender an unreserved apology to be published in the Punch and ThisDay newspapers.

Daniel is also seeking for an order of court to restrain the EFCC from further arresting, detaining or threatening to arrest him. 

 

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment