The Federal High Court on Thursday in Abuja ordered the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Prof. Attahiru Jega, to show cause why he should not be committed to prison for flouting its order.
Read more.....
The court order was contained in form 49 issued by Justice Adamu Bello, copies of which were made available to newsmen in Abuja.
Bello made the declaration in a judgment delivered in a suit filed by an indigenous company, Bedding Holdings Ltd., challenging the use of the boxes for the 2011 general elections.
The court had held that INEC did not seek the consent of the owner of the patent right to the boxes before using them.
The directive of the court was issued pursuant to Order 9 Rule 13 of the Federal High Court procedure rule, compelling Jega to show cause, why order of attachment should not be made against him.
It would be recalled that ionigeria.com had reported that the court on June 5, declared as illegal, the deployment of the collapsible transparent ballot boxes used for the 2011 general elections.
Justice Adamu Bello had then restrained the commission from using the boxes in question for the July 14 Edo State governorship elections.
NAN also recalls that other parties affected by the order are INEC and the Registrar of Patent as well as the Federal Ministry of Commerce and Industry.
The order reads : ``Take notice that the plaintiff will apply to this court for an order for committal to prison the alleged contemnors for having disobeyed the order of this court made on the June 5, 2012 enjoining and restraining you.’’
The Court had restrained the electoral body from using the boxes for any subsequent polls, including the July 14 Edo governorship elections, without first seeking the approval of the patent owner.
The plaintiff had approached the court, contending that it had subsisting exclusive and bona fide patent right to the collapsible transparent boxes used by INEC for the conduct of the 2011 polls.
Bedding Holdings, which specialises in general fabrication and manufacture of steel metal products, said the Collapsible Transparent Ballot
Box was among many of its innovations duly registered with exclusive patent right issued to it by the Registrar of Patent.
The company said that the product was duly registered with exclusive patent right issued to it by the Registrar of Patents in the Federal Ministry of Commerce and Industry.
It said consequently, the Certificate of Registration RP 12994 and Registration of Industrial Designs Rights RD 5946 were issued to the plaintiff by the ministry on Jan. 12, 1998 for five years.
It was renewed and extended on Jan. 12, 2003.
It alleged that INEC violated its rights by its failure to seek its consent before awarding the contract for the procurement of the boxes used for the 2011 general elections.
Following a memorandum by INEC, the Federal Executive Council on Nov. 24, 2010, approved contract for EMCHAI Ltd. to procure 150,000 units of the boxes at N13,000 each totaling N1.9 billion.
Meanwhile, Jega had admitted that INEC deployed the ballot boxes for the Edo polls because it was not possible for the commission to procure new design of the boxes before the elections.
Jega’s admission was contained in an affidavit filed before the court in support of a motion seeking for a stay of execution of the judgment of the court.
The affidavit dated June 28, was deposed to by Mrs Rahima Aminu, who is a legal officer to the commission.
``That I know as a fact that the Ballot Boxes to be used in the said forthcoming elections may be the subject of the injunctive order of this court sought to be stayed from being executed.
``That the Edo State election is due to hold on14th July 2012, three weeks hence.
``That the Ondo State Election is due to hold on 20th October, 2012 four months hence.
``That I know that it is not feasible for the applicant to acquire/procure a new design or different Ballot boxes for the said elections given the short time for the elections.
``The defendants did not have notice of the proceedings leading to the said judgment as it was not properly served with the originating processes and or any other process in the suit leading to the judgment of the court,’’ the deponent stated further
No comments:
Post a Comment